Death Ruled a Homicide as Family Seeks Answers
The family of Daphy Michel, a 31-year-old Haitian immigrant, is preparing to file a lawsuit after she died from hypothermia days after being released from U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) custody in western Pennsylvania. According to her attorney, the legal action is expected to target the United States along with other governmental and non-governmental entities.
Pennsylvania officials ruled Michel’s death a homicide in June. The ruling means her death resulted from another person’s actions, but it does not determine criminal liability. Local investigators continue to examine the circumstances surrounding the case.
Released Alone Before Her Death
Michel had spent several months in county jail following a reported mental health crisis before she was transferred to ICE custody. After a judge dismissed the criminal charges against her, immigration officials released her in Pittsburgh with an ankle monitor.
According to the Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s Office, Michel was a vulnerable adult who had severe untreated mental health issues and faced a significant language barrier. Authorities say she was found days later after spending an extended period near a bus shelter in freezing temperatures while wearing clothing not suited for the weather.
Attorney Questions the Decision
Attorney Joseph Murphy, who represents members of Michel’s family, argues that officials failed to recognize the risks involved in releasing her alone under those conditions. He has said the family believes more safeguards should have been in place given her mental health and inability to safely navigate the situation.
The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has previously stated that ICE was not responsible for Michel’s death. The agency has also disputed aspects of the case, while Michel’s attorney maintains she entered the United States legally, had humanitarian protections, and was pursuing an asylum application.
Surveillance and Ongoing Investigation
Surveillance footage reviewed by local media reportedly showed Michel remaining at a Pittsburgh bus shelter for many hours before she was discovered unresponsive. Emergency responders attempted lifesaving measures, but she later died at a local hospital.
The lawsuit has not yet been filed, and details about the specific claims and defendants have not been made public. Investigators continue reviewing the events surrounding her release and death.
Broader Questions About Vulnerable Detainees
Michel’s case has renewed discussion about how vulnerable individuals are released from immigration custody, particularly those with mental health challenges or limited English proficiency. Advocates say the outcome highlights the importance of ensuring safe transportation, communication, and access to support services when detainees are released.
As the expected lawsuit moves forward, the case is likely to draw renewed attention to policies surrounding the release of individuals from federal immigration custody and the responsibilities agencies have toward vulnerable people in their care.
